20 February
2006
In the
ongoing fight against spyware, Microsoft have released a new version of their
anti-spyware product. While it appears to be an improvement, there are quite a few changes. Because
of these changes, we advise waiting some time before installing it on your system.
The update
has been revamped and renamed Windows
Defender. It has a very different look and feel to the older Microsoft AntiSpyware
and a number of features have been
changed. The main changes seem to be
aimed at making the program more user friendly.
While
being friendly to users is a good
thing, it is possible Windows Defender
has gone a bit too far. The pop-up
warnings on the older spyware program were irritating and sometimes confusing
but did let you know when things
were happening to your system that could be spyware or virus related. We’re not sure if the new program will make
assumptions that might not be correct.
On our
test machines, the program has worked well and picked up some potential spyware
(actually tools we use for virus testing and remote access). But our techs
have seen problems this week and
the Washington Post reports Norton AntiVirus is damaged by it. As a consequence we recommend you do not install
it at this stage.
Beta Software
Windows
Defender, like MS Antispyware, is a beta program, which means it is still
being tested. Generally we don’t recommend running Beta
software on home and business machines,
we made an exception for the MS Antispyware beta because it was little more than a re-badged version
of the Giant AntiSpyware product. The Windows Defender is a much different
beast and so our general rule of
not running betas on production
machines applies.
Initially
it appears to be a good product,
however we feel it’s probably best
to leave it for a few weeks until we get a better
feel for it’s stability.
We should note that no program is the complete solution to avoiding spyware
and viruses. Defender, the Microsoft Anti spyware and all the other software
and tactics we recommend for avoiding spyware are only part of a bigger picture.